Introduction
In the previous installment of this series, we discussed unfair competition as a defense against product imitations. However, unfair competition is not the only avenue, and in certain factual circumstances, it may not provide a sufficient basis for potential action against manufacturers or sellers of imitations. Manufacturers of original products should also consider the protection afforded by the registration of non-conventional trade marks, under the Copyright Act, and through the registration of a design. Each of these instruments protects something different and has different prerequisites and limitations. Unlike unfair competition, which in principle requires no prior action on the part of manufacturers of original products, these other tools, however, require certain steps to be taken even before imitations are sold. In this second installment of the series, we will explain the differences between these means of protection and show when it is appropriate to use each one.
1. Non-Conventional Trade Marks
A trade mark protects a sign that consumers associate with a specific business. Its essence lies primarily in its distinguishing function—that is, providing information that a product has a specific origin. It requires registration, but its protection is potentially unlimited in duration if properly maintained and used.
However, in the case of imitation products, the protection provided by a word mark for the product name or by a figurative mark, with or without word elements, for the manufacturer’s logo is generally insufficient. Lookalikes typically do not copy the name of a competitor’s product or its manufacturer’s logo, but rather seek to evoke an association with such a product by imitating its overall impression, appearance, color or graphic elements, etc.
Therefore, it is important to consider the possibility of protection through non-conventional trade marks. These include shape marks protecting the three-dimensional shape of a product or its packaging—for example, the shape of a bottle or a package. A position mark, on the other hand, provides protection for the placement of a specific design element on a product—such as a stripe on a shoe. In addition to a logo, a figurative mark can also protect the design of a label, a distinctive pattern, or individual graphic elements. It is also possible to obtain a trade mark for a color or color combination that is sufficiently distinctive for the product in question.
Czech courts have repeatedly confirmed that likelihood of confusion need not stem from the imitation of a word element—the imitation of a visual pattern or the shape of a product may therefore be sufficient.
In the Louis Vuitton case, the Supreme Administrative Court heard a case involving a discount retailer that offered women’s handbags with a checkerboard pattern confusingly similar to Louis Vuitton’s checkerboard pattern (Damier), for which figurative marks had been registered. The court concluded that even the protected checkerboard pattern on the handbag itself could be confusingly similar and enjoys protection, despite the fact that the discount retailer used it without the Louis Vuitton logo. The absence of the “Louis Vuitton” inscription or the “LV” initials is irrelevant, as these elements may not even appear on the original products. Nor did a paper tag bearing the retailer’s own logo eliminate the likelihood of confusion, and the court also rejected the argument that consumers could not mistake discount goods for luxury goods—the fact that the customer base is different does not preclude awareness of the brand and its products, and what matters is the likelihood of confusion, not actual confusion.1
The shape of a sole may also be protected as a shape mark, as the Supreme Administrative Court confirmed in the Converse case. The court heard a case involving the sale of shoes whose sole design was nearly identical to the shape mark of Converse shoes. Even the licensed motifs on the plaintiff’s footwear (Hello Kitty, Hannah Montana) could not rule out the likelihood of confusion with this shape mark, as manufacturers of high-top sneakers, including Converse itself, also use popular motifs on their footwear. The court further emphasized that while the five-pointed star and the “CONVERSE” inscription are indeed characteristic features, they are not present on all types of footwear, whereas the protected sole design is, and that it is irrelevant what types of soles other competitors manufacture. The likelihood of confusion between products must be assessed based on the overall (particularly visual) impression and consumers’ awareness of the trade mark.2
The overall impression test has also been applied in cases involving imitation perfumes. An illustrative example is the judgment of the Regional Court in Ostrava3 in which the court upheld the customs authorities’ action against a seller offering, among other things, two perfumes labeled “Farenhit” and two perfumes featuring an image of a blooming red poppy. Regarding the verbal imitation, the court concurred with the conclusion that the omission of two letters (H and E) compared to the international trade mark registration “Fahrenheit” owned by Parfums Christian Dior “indicates a completely obvious attempt to avoid using the same verbal name, while giving the impression, upon inattentive, superficial reading, that it is the Fahrenheit perfume.” As for the figurative imitation, the depiction of a poppy in conjunction with the inscriptions “Keen Zonet” and “Story of Flower,” respectively, and with the type of goods for which the KENZO figurative mark is registered, created a likelihood of confusion with the Flower by Kenzo series. However, when registering non-conventional trade marks, greater attention may be required regarding their distinctiveness for the relevant product. They will often lack an inherent distinctive character. This will then require the manufacturer or seller of such a product to gather evidence to demonstrate the distinctive character acquired through use. Furthermore, an important limitation of shape marks is that they cannot protect a shape which results from the nature of the goods themselves, a shape necessary to obtain a technical result, or a shape which gives substantial value to the goods. This must be kept in mind in advance when designing a product so that its shape does not subsequently preclude the possibility of protection.
2. Copyright Protection of Unique Graphic Designs
Copyright protects works that are the unique outcome of the author’s creative activity. A prerequisite for claiming protection is therefore proving a certain level of originality in the work, which requires the manufacturer to preserve evidence of authorship and the date of creation before any infringement of such copyright occurs. Through copyright, it is thus also possible to protect the original graphic design of packaging or a product, or an original logo. Unlike a trade mark, it does not require any registration—it arises automatically upon the creation of the work. The duration of this protection, however, is limited to the author’s lifetime and 70 years after his or her death.
A product design may therefore qualify as a copyright work if it meets the required level of originality. In its decision in the “Páv” and “Gotika” Decors case, the Supreme Court upheld copyright protection for unique cut-glass decors. The plaintiff’s “Páv” and “Gotika” decors were so original that they met the defining features of a work, with the uniqueness of the creative result stemming from the unique composition and combination of classic glass-cutting elements in an elaborate cut. In this case, the defendants used these protected decors on their products without a proper license from the plaintiff; the courts also found that one of the defendants had engaged in free-riding on the plaintiff’s reputation, as the name of a fictitious author was used on some of the products.4 A fundamental limitation of protection, however, is that copyright does not protect an idea, concept, or functional solution—only their specific creative expression, such as on a product’s packaging. In the Didaktis case, the action alleging imitation of textbooks was unsuccessful because the underlying idea and concept of the textbook—which determines the selection and organization of content, as well as the scope, execution, and arrangement of individual elements (including the so-called visual layer of the concept)—do not meet the defining features of a copyright work. From the perspective of unfair competition, the courts found that the plaintiff was neither the only nor the first to place this type of textbook on the market, and that the defendant’s textbooks had a completely different design for the title page, the dominant element of which was precisely the defendant’s logo—which was sufficient to distinguish them. The Supreme Court dismissed the appellate review.5
3. Designs for the Appearance of a Product
Designs protect the appearance of a product, particularly its shapes, lines, colors, texture, or material. They are thus an ideal tool for defending against products that imitate the appearance or impression of the original. However, a design cannot be used to obtain protection for features of appearance solely dictated by technical function.
Unlike copyright, designs do not require creative originality, but rather novelty and individual character—the appearance of the product must not have been previously disclosed to the public and must produce a different overall impression in an informed user compared to previously disclosed designs. Another condition for protection—unlike under copyright law—is the registration of a national design with the Czech Industrial Property Office or an EU design with EUIPO. The term of protection is also more limited, as it is capped at 25 years.
An important aspect of protection is the standard used to assess the likelihood of confusion between an imitation and a design. While in cases of unfair competition involving the assessment of the likelihood of confusion between an imitation and the original, the impression of the average consumer is decisive, in the case of designs, the standard of the so-called informed user applies. This refers to a person who is familiar with various designs existing in the relevant industry, possesses a certain degree of knowledge regarding the elements that such designs typically contain, and exercises a relatively high degree of attention when using the products in question.6 An illustrative example is the CROCS case, in which two designs from the same detained consignment of plastic footwear were assessed differently: for 3,240 pairs with circular holes, the courts found an infringement of a registered design and classified them as counterfeits, whereas for 1,800 pairs with heart-shaped holes, the courts concluded that the shape and placement of the holes are precisely what catches the informed user’s eye and creates a different overall impression than that of the registered design. The Supreme Court dismissed the appellate review.7 The overall impression of an informed user may differ from the impression the design makes on an ordinary consumer, as an informed user may notice differences that are not at all apparent to an ordinary consumer. The legal framework for EU design protection also provides for the possibility of obtaining protection for an unregistered EU design, which arises upon its first disclosure to the public. Unlike a registered design, however, obtaining protection requires proving that the imitator copied the unregistered design, which increases the evidentiary burden for manufacturers or sellers of original products in the event of a dispute with the imitator. Furthermore, the protection granted lasts only 3 years from the date of disclosure to the public. While this may be sufficient for some fast-moving consumer goods, for key products in a portfolio, an unregistered EU design should serve at most as a first level of protection, supplemented by additional layers such as registered designs and non-conventional trade marks.
Conclusion
However, none of these tools provides complete protection on its own. It is always necessary to weigh which tool to use depending on the individual elements of a product’s appearance and, at the same time, the overall impression these elements create for the consumer.
A layered strategy is therefore the most effective—a combination of multiple tools along with unfair competition measures, which we discussed in the previous installment of this series. Only such a strategy can ensure that the manufacturer or seller of the original product is prepared to defend against imitators.
In the next installment, we will focus on key steps in the fight against imitations: how to monitor dupes, why prevention through IP portfolio management is important, when to seek preliminary injunctions, why it makes sense to cooperate with customs authorities and e-commerce platforms, and more.
- Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court dated March 31, 2014, Ref. No. 4 As 112/2013-104. ↩︎
- Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court dated February 13, 2014, Ref. No. 9 As 49/2013-44. ↩︎
- Judgment of the Regional Court in Ostrava dated June 25, 2015, Ref. No. 22 Af 75/2013-31. ↩︎
- Judgment of the Supreme Court dated November 28, 2024, Case No. 23 Cdo 55/2024. ↩︎
- Resolution of the Supreme Court dated May 29, 2024, Case No. 23 Cdo 2733/2023; the constitutional complaint was dismissed by a resolution of the Constitutional Court dated September 30, 2024, Case No. III. ÚS 2380/24. ↩︎
- Judgment of the Court of Justice dated October 20, 2011, PepsiCo v. Grupo Promer Mon Graphic, C-281/10 P, EU:C:2011:679; this judgment was followed by a judgment of the Supreme Court dated November 25, 2014, Case No. 23 Cdo 2887/2013. ↩︎
- Resolution of the Supreme Court dated April 25, 2017, Case No. 23 Cdo 116/2017. ↩︎