
Background
In this fourth instalment of our series of alerts on the new subscription contract rules, we explore the cooling-off and cancellation rights provided to consumers, including the implications for businesses of the new renewal cooling-off periods and liability for refunds.
Cooling-off and cancellation rights
Under the existing Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 (“CCRs”), consumers generally have a statutory 14-day cooling-off period when entering into a distance or off-premises contract, during which they can cancel without penalty and obtain a refund. Under the new subscription rules, this will also apply to contracts entered into on-premises. The new rules also add a cooling-off right at specified renewal events.
For contracts entered into on or after 1 January 2027, consumers will have a cooling-off period at the following specified intervals:
| Initial cooling-off period | – upon initially entering into the subscription contract (as currently) |
| Renewal cooling-off period | – when the consumer becomes liable for a payment or higher payment following the end of a free or discounted concessionary period where a subscription auto-renews into a paid or full-price contract; and -upon a subscription auto-renewing for a contract period lasting 12 months or more. |
When a consumer cancels during either cooling-off period, the contract ends immediately, with neither party obliged to perform future obligations. The trader must send an end-of-contract notice confirming the date on which the contract is cancelled. The consumer may also be entitled to a refund as set out below.
Cancellation during the initial cooling-off period also automatically cancels any ancillary contracts relating to the subscription, and the main trader must inform any other trader providing an ancillary contract.
As under the CCRs, the consumer must provide the trader with a clear statement of their decision to cancel. The burden of proof of sending a clear statement to cancel is on the consumer, who should retain durable proof. Unlike under the CCRs, there is no model withdrawal form to provide to consumers.
Refunds
Where a consumer exercises the cooling-off right, the refund that they will be entitled to will depend on what is being supplied and the extent to which it has already been supplied:
Services
- Consumers will receive a full refund where the supply has not begun. If supply began during the initial cooling-off period with the consumer’s valid express consent and the trader complied with the applicable requirements, the trader may retain an amount proportionate to the service supplied before cancellation.
- A similar proportionate approach applies during a renewal cooling-off period where the cooling-off notice requirements were met.
- Hired goods are treated similarly to services for refund purposes.
Digital Content
- For subscriptions covering digital content only, if the consumer expressly consents to waive their initial cooling-off period rights in return for immediate supply of the digital content (and acknowledges and receives confirmation of the same), they will not receive a refund if they cancel during the initial cooling-off period; if the consumer has not validly waived their right to cancel during the initial cooling-off period, they are not liable to pay for digital content supplied during that period.
- o Consumers cannot waive their renewal cooling-off right. If the consumer cancels during a renewal cooling-off period, the trader may retain a proportionate amount for the content supplied prior to cancellation provided that the required cooling-off notice was given.
Goods
- Returnable goods: Consumers will generally be entitled to a full refund (including standard delivery costs) for returned goods.
- Perishable or bespoke goods: Where a contract supplies exclusively perishable or bespoke goods, the consumer’s initial cooling-off right may be exercised only during the 14 days beginning with the day after the contract is entered into, provided that the trader has supplied the prescribed information – rather than when first supply occurs.
- Sealed or inseparably mixed goods: Consumers may remain liable where specified sealed goods are unsealed after delivery or have become inseparably mixed, provided that the trader complied with the prescribed information requirements.
Refunds must be made without undue delay and generally within 14 days beginning with the day after cancellation. Where the consumer is responsible for returning goods, the period instead begins on the day after the trader receives the goods or, if earlier, evidence that the goods were sent.
Much of this will be familiar from the CCRs, though for mixed subscriptions, note that proportionate refunds have to be calculated separately for each of the goods, services or digital content supplied before cancellation. The guidance envisages that traders may prefer to provide a full refund if, for example, the calculation would be too administratively burdensome. In addition, note that consumers cannot waive their initial cooling-off right for digital content provided under the same contract as goods or services.
Cancellation for breach of an implied term
Cooling-off rights are distinct from a consumer’s right to bring a contract to an end before renewal (often referred to as ‘exit’) and from any rights to cancel as a result of a breach by a trader of an implied term. The changes introduce a separate cancellation right where the trader breaches certain implied terms, including terms concerning key pre-contract information and reminder notices, or failure to facilitate straightforward exit.
This right is generally exercisable for 12 months beginning with the day after the specified ‘relevant date’ (which varies depending on the type of implied term breached). Cancellation may extinguish the consumer’s liability for certain payments and require corresponding refunds, subject to the detailed rules, including those concerning unreasonable delay.
Consequences of non-compliance
If a trader fails to comply with the new requirements, the relevant cooling-off period may be extended by up to a further 12 months. Other consequences include losing the right to retain payment for goods, services or digital content supplied before cancellation, and the ability to make deductions from refunds. Breaches may also expose traders to private claims and public enforcement, including substantial potential financial penalties of up to £300,000 or 10% of global annual turnover, whichever is higher.
Next steps
Businesses should take steps to identify and implement the changes to their systems and processes required for compliance with the new subscription requirements ahead of 1 January 2027.
Longer term, businesses operating across the UK and EU will also need to consider the impact of the EU Digital Fairness Act Proposal.
Baker McKenzie supports businesses with risk assessments of subscription models, advice on practical changes to products and systems, and engagement with consumer regulators.
For more information, please contact the Baker McKenzie Consumer Law Team.